Simonton Street runs north-south through Old Town Key West, positioned exactly one block east of Duval Street. It extends from the northern harbor at Front Street down to South Street near the Atlantic Ocean.
Guide to Simonton Street in Key West
Simonton Street runs parallel to Duval Street as a quiet, tree-shaded corridor through Old Town Key West. The street features historic Conch cottages, literary landmarks, and public harbor access away from crowded commercial avenues. Riding the Conch Tour Train offers an introductory overview of Old Town landmarks before travelers explore Simonton Street on foot.
Tour Key West and Simonton Street With Conch Tour Train
- 60-Minute Historic Loop: Ride through Old Town to view historic architecture and residential corridors from an open-air seat.
- Front Street Depot Departures: Board the Conch Tour Train at the downtown depot located steps from the waterfront and northern Simonton Street.
- Engaging Island Narration: Listen to drivers share island lore, cigar-making history, and stories of notable residents like Ernest Hemingway.
- Station Depot Rest Stop: Enjoy a scheduled 10-minute break for refreshments and shopping at the corner of Front and Duval Streets.
- Avoid Driving and Parking: Tour the historic district comfortably without walking long stretches in the midday heat or searching for street parking.
Key Features of Simonton Street
- Casa Antigua and the Pelican Poop Shop: Visit 314 Simonton Street to see the 1919 former Trev-Mor Hotel where Ernest Hemingway finished “A Farewell to Arms,” featuring 3-foot-thick brick walls and a garden atrium shop.
- Simonton Street Beach: Relax at 0 Simonton Street, a public pocket beach located at the northern end of the road offering harbor views of sailboats and passing ships.
- Simonton Court Historic Inn & Cottages: View the restored 1880s compound at 320 Simonton Street, which originally operated as a Cuban cigar factory and worker housing.
- Preserved Conch Cottages: Photograph residential cottages between Front Street and South Street featuring tin roofs, shaded porches, and gingerbread wood trim.
Discover Simonton Street
Key West’s Hidden Historic Escape
When travelers arrive in Old Town Key West, their eyes usually turn toward the lively energy of Duval Street. Just one block to the east sits a peaceful, tree-shaded thoroughfare offering a wonderfully relaxed atmosphere.
Running parallel to the main tourist strip, Simonton Street provides a scenic retreat where historic Victorian homes, lush botanical gardens, and charming boutique inns replace crowded bar venues. This alternative invites visitors to slow down and enjoy the architectural beauty of the Conch Republic. Whether you are seeking historic sights, literary lore, or unique things to do on Simonton Street, this guide showcases one of the most delightful neighborhood routes in Old Town Key West.
From Founding Proprietor to Historic Corridor
Understanding the charm of Simonton Street begins with the origins of modern Key West itself.
The Founding Father of Key West
Businessman with a Vision
This historic avenue carries the name of John W. Simonton, an enterprising American businessman who purchased the entire island of Key West from Juan Pablo Salas in December 1821 for $2,000. Simonton recognized the strategic value of the island’s deepwater harbor. In 1822, he coordinated with the United States government to establish a naval presence, creating the foundation for our commercial maritime economy and launching the modern American era of the island.
A Hub of 19th-Century Commerce
As Key West grew throughout the 1800s, Simonton Street developed into a thriving corridor of industry. Cuban cigar masters established hand-rolling factories along these blocks, surrounding their production facilities with neat rows of wooden worker cottages. Maritime trades, shipping offices, and local supply shops lined the street, connecting the busy northern waterfront directly to the residential neighborhoods extending south.
Architectural Preservation Along the Corridor
Walking down the sidewalk today offers a wonderful look at preserved 19th-century craftwork. Intricate gingerbread wood trim adorns front porches, metal tin roofs catch the afternoon sun, and pastel paint colors decorate historic cottages. Careful restoration work across decades has protected these structures, ensuring the street maintains its authentic maritime character for generations of travelers exploring Old Town Key West.
Hemingway Lore and Brick Walls
Beyond its early business history, Simonton Street holds a special place in world literary history.
The Story of Casa Antigua
Located at 314 Simonton Street, Casa Antigua stands as one of the most distinctive historic buildings in Old Town Key West. Built in 1919 as The Trev-Mor Hotel, this structure was designed to be completely fireproof. The builders constructed 3-foot-thick walls using hand-molded red bricks salvaged from 1845 construction efforts at nearby Fort Zachary Taylor. The building also featured an open-air central atrium, creating a natural air conditioning system that channeled ocean breezes through the interior corridors.
A Fortuitous Car Delay
In April 1928, a young Ernest Hemingway arrived in Key West alongside his wife Pauline. Their plan was to collect a new Ford car promised by Pauline’s uncle and drive north to mainland Florida. The automobile delivery was delayed, leaving the couple stranded on the island for several weeks. Local hotel operator Charles Trevrette invited them to stay in a top-floor room at The Trev-Mor Hotel on Simonton Street.
Falling in Love With the Island
During this unexpected stay, Hemingway fell deeply in love with the island lifestyle. He spent his mornings on the hotel roof working tirelessly to complete his famous World War I novel, “A Farewell to Arms.” In the afternoons, he explored local fishing piers, made lifelong friends among island residents, and discovered the unique community spirit that convinced him to make Key West his permanent home.
Simonton Court Historic Inn & Cottages
Further down the block sits Simonton Court, another remarkable site brimming with local history. Originally constructed in the 1880s as a cigar manufacturing compound, this property once housed a factory building, brick warehouses, and residential cottages. Today, the site has been meticulously transformed into a historic garden inn, where restored cottages sit nestled amid tropical palms and floral gardens.
Key Stops and Things To Do
Exploring the variety of things to do on Simonton Street reveals fantastic stops along its north-south path from Front Street down to South Street.
Simonton Street Beach
At the northern terminus of the street sits Simonton Street Beach, located at 0 Simonton Street. This charming public harbor pocket beach offers clear views of passing sailboats, cruise ships, and charter craft navigating Key West Harbor. Visitors can rest on the sand, watch incoming boats, or dip their feet into the warm waters of the Gulf of Mexico.
Casa Antigua and the Pelican Poop Shoppe
Stepping inside 314 Simonton Street brings guests directly into the historic atrium where Ernest Hemingway once walked. The ground floor houses the Pelican Poop Shoppe, a delightful gift store filled with tropical Caribbean art, unique souvenirs, and handcrafted home decor. Visitors can admire the soaring brick walls and lush garden plants surrounding the central courtyard.
Simonton Court Historic Inn & Cottages
Located at 320 Simonton Street, this property showcases classic island preservation. Guests strolling past can admire original 1880s brickwork and restored wooden facades tucked behind shade trees and tropical foliage.
Historic Cottage Photography
Walking the southern blocks toward South Street reveals quiet residential sections lined with preserved architecture. Photography enthusiasts love capturing the pastel-painted homes, wooden shutters, and flowering bougainvillea that frame the brick sidewalks throughout Old Town Key West.
Exploring Surrounding Old Town
The central position of Simonton Street places travelers within easy walking distance of top cultural sights and historic landmarks across the island.
Key West Historic Seaport
Located at the northern foot of the street, the Key West Historic Seaport offers a vibrant quarter-mile harbor walk. Visitors can watch fishing charters unload their daily catch, dine on fresh local seafood, or book snorkeling excursions out to coral reefs.
St. Paul's Episcopal Church
Stretching between Duval Street and Simonton Street on Eaton Street, St. Paul’s Episcopal Church represents the oldest religious congregation in South Florida, established in 1832. The current Gothic Revival structure features stained-glass windows depicting sea life and historic island events.
Mallory Square
Situated two short blocks west along Front Street, Mallory Square serves as the focal point for oceanfront views. Every evening, street performers, local artisans, and visitors gather along the harbor to celebrate the sunset over the Gulf horizon.
The Marquesa Hotel
Located a short stroll away on Fleming Street, The Marquesa Hotel consists of a complex of 19th-century restored homes surrounding garden courtyards. It features one of the finest dining rooms on the island, showcasing fresh regional seafood and fine cuisine.
Key West Shipwreck Treasure Museum
Positioned near Mallory Square, the Key West Shipwreck Treasure Museum brings the 1850s wrecking era back to life. Guests can explore salvaged treasures recovered from sunken ships, interact with historical storytellers, and climb the 65-foot observation tower for views across Key West Harbor.
The Smartest Way To Tour Key West
Exploring the quiet charm of Simonton Street and uncovering the full story of Old Town Key West provides an unforgettable vacation experience. Walking across the island under the tropical sun can become tiring during warm afternoon hours. Navigating narrow historic lanes and hunting for limited street parking can also take away precious time from your vacation schedule.
Hop aboard the world-famous Conch Tour Train for a seamless sightseeing adventure! The 60-minute narrated tour begins at the Front Street Depot, taking you on an entertaining loop through Old Town Key West. Guests enjoy a 10-minute refreshment and shopping break at the station depot at the corner of Front and Duval Streets.
As you ride through historic neighborhood blocks, our expert drivers provide an amusing narrative filled with historical facts, local trivia, and stories of the colorful personalities who shaped our island. You will gain a wonderful overview of top landmarks, marine sites, and historic architecture without worrying about heat or traffic.
Ernest Hemingway stayed at 314 Simonton Street inside the former Trev-Mor Hotel (now Casa Antigua) in 1928. During his stay, he completed his famous World War I novel, “A Farewell to Arms.”
Yes, Simonton Street Beach sits at the northern end of the street at 0 Simonton Street. It is a small public pocket beach along Key West Harbor, offering water access and pier views.
Yes! The Conch Tour Train loops through historic Old Town Key West, treating guests to close-up views of iconic landmarks, maritime sites, historic homes, and top neighborhood attractions.
History enthusiasts can visit Casa Antigua at 314 Simonton Street to see where Ernest Hemingway lived, photograph restored 19th-century cigar worker cottages at Simonton Court, and admire Victorian architecture along the residential blocks.
Simonton Street runs parallel to Duval Street just one block to the east, making it an easy, peaceful walking alternative when traveling north or south across Old Town Key West.
Yes, the corridor features charming historic bed-and-breakfasts, boutique inns like Simonton Court, local cafes, and fine-dining options located near key street corners.
The Conch Tour Train was created on January 18, 1958, by Bill and Olive Kroll after they saw a train tour in Helena, Montana. They started with one train, #97, with Bill driving and Olive selling tickets on Front Street before adding more trains and growing into the beloved Historic Tours of America® attraction that operates today.
The tour officially begins at the Front Street Depot. During the 60-minute loop through Old Town Key West, the train makes a 10-minute stop at the station depot located at the corner of Front and Duval Streets, where guests can pause for refreshments and shopping before finishing the ride.